| Year Inducted | Hall of Famer(s) Inducted |
|---|---|
| 1999 | Alan DeWorth, Joe McCafferty, Frank Solich, John Winkel |
| 2000 | Emmett Donelon, Stephen Hanigosky, Msgr. James McIntyre |
| 2001 | Eddie Dwyer, Bernie Heneghan, James Reddy |
| 2002 | Bernie Clark, Jerry Madden, Tony McDaniel, Jack Natale |
| 2003 | Rev. James McGonegal, Frank Musco, Phil Swinderman, Rich Wild |
| 2004 | Douglas Kokoskie, Chris Jarus, Dave Wild |
| 2005 | Msgr. Albert Murphy, John Cheklo Jr., Kevin "Bo" Kuntz |
| 2006 | Louise Furjanic, Patrick McDaniel, Brian Wypasek |
| 2007 | David Szymczak, Patrick Doc Gallagher, Jay Westbrook, Dennis M. Donelon |
| 2008 | Bob Smith, Dave Emery, Dan Reiser, Walter E. Martens Jr. |
| 2009 | Frank Evans, Anthony Sidoti, Bruce Bethany |
| 2010 | Mike Harris, Neil Hubert, George Colbert |
| 2011 | Jack Smith, Dan Urban, Pete Campbell |
| 2012 | Denise Steve, Dan Dehil, Buddy & Ceil Graves |
| 2013 | Pete Laktovic, George Hohman |
| 2014 | Peter "Bob" Lungo, Raymond Szczepaniak |
| 2016 | Jeffrey Harris, Dennis Kilbane, Andrew Suvak, Donna Woods |
| 2017 | Ronald Bunner, Pat Campbell, Brian Kilbane, Devon Wood |
| 2018 | Jordan Johnson, David Woods |
| 2022 | Joe Callahan, Lorraine Rakoczy, Angela Valentine |